Spot (Superdog) and his various superhero friends are celebrating the success of their new movie "The Adventures of Spot: The Movie", which currently rated 99% percent on Bland Tomatoes. They realize someone has given their film a negative review, the critic stating he just thinks superheroes are dumb. The other heroes do not stand for this, and take that Bat-Bat Mobile-Mobile to find him.
Spot imagines the critic as a typical villain, but upon arrival to his house, find out he's merely a scrawny nerd. The critic lambasts them for threatening to beat him up for having his own opinion. Spot tells him to remove the bias from his review, but the critic tells him he only likes one film: "The Green Lamp". The Krunlk then tries to quash him.
Mr. Sorcerer tells the others that the critic merely has poor taste, and that he deserves pity, not scorn, which the critic doesn't want (but Spot threatens him to take it.) The critic argues that the only reason they care so much because there is a consensus praising the film. The critic mentions that a lot of people liked "Blue Space Indians." Later, everyone is seen at a bar, Spot saying that movies are stupid.