Peanut and Grape, dressed in their Halloween costumes, return from a substandard Halloween event (with a field maze made from a potato patch.) Grape complains about wanting to experience something actually spooky...until they discover a video rental store (as an ominous flash of lightning strikes overhead.)
They enter the store, browsing through the section when a mysterious store clerk with a Russian accent joins them. He offers to show them something "unique" and takes them to the basement sector (which he claims was from when the store was a Sizzler.) He hands them an unmarked DVD, warning them that it has been returned many times...each time more terrible than the last...until Grape asks whether or not it is cursed.
After leaving the store, the duo notice the store has mysteriously vanished. Peanut momentarily freaks out, wondering if any of it actually happened, until the store returns as a coffee shop instead. The two agree the DVD is cursed and not to watch it and let Tarot or Sabrina deal with it. After a moment's thought, the two go home and watch it anyways, where it turns out to be a copy of The Ring.